Review: Photography Magazines
Knowledge - Self-Portrait - 17-55mm |
As I said I would, I am writing a blog about photography magazines. Personally I have asked many people's opinions on what photography magazine is best. I usually got varying response since a lot of it is what type of photography you do and what your own interests are. So with that said this is all my opinion about what magazines I like most or ones I don't like so much. I have had three different subscriptions to different magazines and I have bought a lot whenever I see a magazine that looks like it has good information at stores. Also one thing I highly recommend is going to your local library to see if they have any photography magazines. Mine has Photo Life and Popular Photography. It is kind of nice going to the library with my dad and reading their photography magazines while my dad reads his book. It's free and I have only one complaint here, which is just that I can't refer back to any article in the future. But personally I have a pretty good memory for things if I enjoy the subject matter.
I currently have a little over twenty magazines now. I have mostly Outdoor Photographer but I have five or so Digital Photos as well as five or so Photo Lifes. I have one Shutterbug and just this year have gotten Digital SLR Photography magazines which are made in the UK. I first got the Digital SLR photography with was their Essential Guide to Landscape Photography. This was an amazing magazine which got me looking for others like it and found they wrote a monthly magazine as well. This magazine made me want to write this blog because prior to these UK magazines, I never really had a magazine that was that much better than the others I bought.
So I will go through my thoughts on the different magazines I have read and let you know why I like or dislike them. And lastly I will go over my favourite.
First I will go over Photo Life magazine. It is a very clean and crisp magazine. Professional setup and layout and sometimes does have some good gems of articles. However they are a little on the smallish side. My brother got me a subscription to the magazine and it was great however sometimes you could get it and the main article was on photoshop shortcuts. This would be great for people with this program however not so much for people like me who have a different editing software. So that issue itself, of the magazine, was almost a write off. So in my experience it is a little hit and miss for this magazine. Sometimes I love reading it and sometimes the issue I get doesn't have much for me. So for me I still will pick one up at a store and scan it to see if I should buy it but I don't think I would get another subscription to it. Also they have it at my library so I usually read it there.
Another magazine I had a subscription for was Digital Photo. It was also another gift but this time from my girlfriend at the time. I bought a copy of this magazine and loved it. Covered some great content so I asked for that as a Xmas present. The issues after that were not near the one I bought sadly. They are mediocre most of the time. So again this magazine, like Photo Life, is one I'll scan through before buying but I wont buy a subscription. It wasn't as professional looking as Photo Life and seemed to be tailored to maybe a more younger amateur level of photographer. Not that that is bad by any means, I just think for the large majority of the articles, I knew enough of what they were saying already and I did not benefit enough from the articles.
Outdoor Photographer is a good solid magazine. I don't mean you could hammer nails with it but it usually has good helpful articles. Most of my magazine collection consists of these and I am usually not disappointed with them. I would say they usually have articles that match with my type of photography and if not, they are still usually good reads. I would recommend this magazine if you like photographing the outdoors and wildlife. These magazines are usually long so you have more articles and therefore a better chance one fits with the areas of photography that you like.
I have one Shutterbug magazine and I think from the fact I just have one speaks on my opinion of it. It had tons of ads in it. So many it makes it hard to read which is too bad. I actually wrote most of this blog on my iPhone between classes however edited it when I got home and I just looked through my Shutterbug magazine. For about 80% of the magazine or more, there was an ad on every other page. The two main articles were last in the magazine pretty much and, didn't have any ads in them. However right after the two main articles... the two page spreads for camera companies. If this magazine isn't making boat loads of money from ads, I don't think anyone can. From my photo above with me and my magazines I remembered all of the articles on the pages I opened the magazines to for the most part. The Shutterbug one, not so much.
Popular Photography is a magazine I only read when I go to my local library. It isn't great but it's not bad. It's about the exact same as Digital Photo. Geared towards younger amateurs and set up in a way to try to grab your attention with ads and I guess the word for it is cluttered. It sometimes has good articles but I can't really remember what I've read in them. So it is a magazine that I would read but definitely not buy. I am sure it might suit some readers out there but I am just a little too advanced for it maybe and the articles don't help me a lot. I still read them to get as much knowledge as I can but this magazine would not be my number one pick.
Lastly the Digital SLR photography. First I'll review their Essential Guides then I'll cover the monthly issues. I have the Essential Guide to Landscape Photography and their Essential Guide to Outdoor Photography. Both were some of the best sources of helpful information I have seen. I loved to read these magazines. The landscapes from the UK which definitely helped for I do have a soft spot for landscapes in Scotland. The magazines almost had no ads as well as they were huge in terms of length, width and height. The tips are extremely helpful, the guides are very good and the types of articles are very well thought out. The advice and ideas they go over are accurate and useful. I have read many articles discussing what it was like to go take photos in Alaska or other neat places but they never really give you a ton of information on how to do it. These magazines go over everything with enough detail that the only information missing is what you will learn if you go out there and try the techniques or ideas yourself. The Essential Guide to Outdoor Photography is 162 pages long and is jam packed with information front to back. These are well worth their weight in gold. I am going to try to get my hands on the portrait one (The Essential Guide to Portrait Photography).
As for the Digital SLR photography monthly issues, they are just as good (if not better because they are monthly). The last issue I got (Nov, 2011 Issue 60) has 145 pages before the camera store ads come up. So again, full of tons of very helpful topics and advice. This issue has 101 portrait "gems" which I did like a lot. I knew most of the advice however it is nice to have it all in the same spot if I ever need some motivation or different ideas for portraits. I could go on and on about these magazines but they are basically the same as the Essential Guides, but just more of a spectrum of topics covered. But these magazines and the Essential Guides (which I am 95% sure they are from the same company) are by far the best photography magazines I have read.
So in conclusion, if you want a sophisticated magazine that is of professional level, go for the Photo Life magazine however be prepared that the articles might not always be what you are looking for. Popular Photography/Digital Photography are similar to each other and are geared below Photo Life at younger amateurs I think. They are good and general however I found I was a little advanced for a lot of their articles, or I was doing different types of photography than what they were covering. Shutterbug is great if you want to read more ads than articles. Outdoor Photographer is a decent magazine and is the magazine I have bought most consistently. They were good but I wouldn't say they were amazing and stood out a lot against the other magazines. Since the articles are more geared to outdoor photography like the name implies, the articles have a better chance to fit with what I want to read about. But then along came Digital SLR photography. The Essential Guide to Landscape Photography and The Essential Guide to Outdoor Photography were amazing and definitely trumped the Outdoor Photographer magazines. And that might be an understatement. I do love nature photography especially landscape and macro but I do also do portraiture so I in need for a magazine that had more than just insects, flowers and mountains. Then I found the Digital SLR photography monthly magazines and I was sold. If you know of any other good magazines please let me know but right now I don't see anything topping these Digital SLR photography magazines. So 10 points to you, Digital SLR photography, for making a very good magazine and essential guides.
Again just to add somewhat of a disclaimer here, these are just my opinions and a lot of what makes or breaks a magazine is the content. And some content could put me to sleep while others could be put on the edge of their chairs. So to each their own.
Hope that helps,
Tom
Just re-reviewed my magazine selection for my youtube channel which you can check out here: http://youtu.be/WOIO1uPnud0